Estate planning in the UK often begins with making a will. For couples, particularly married partners and civil partners, one of the most popular choices is a mirror will. These wills are drafted in identical terms, ensuring that each person leaves their estate to the other, and typically, after both partners have passed away, the estate goes to the same beneficiaries, often children or other relatives.
At first glance, mirror wills seem straightforward, cost-effective, and practical. But like many legal tools, they come with both advantages and disadvantages. Understanding mirror wills pros and cons is essential if you are considering them as part of your estate planning.
By the end, you should have a clear, balanced view of whether mirror wills align with your needs, or whether a different legal arrangement would better protect your estate and beneficiaries.
What Are Mirror Wills in the UK?
Mirror wills are essentially two separate but nearly identical wills, usually created by couples in long-term relationships, whether married, in a civil partnership, or cohabiting. Each partner’s will “mirrors” the other: one person leaves everything to the surviving partner, and then, once both have passed, their combined estate is distributed to agreed beneficiaries, often children, grandchildren, or other relatives.
Although sometimes confused with joint wills, mirror wills are legally distinct. A joint will is a single document binding both partners, whereas mirror wills are two individual legal documents that stand on their own. This distinction is important because it gives each partner legal autonomy, though the intention is usually aligned.
Key features of mirror wills include:
- Mutual structure: Each will reflects the same provisions, typically leaving the estate first to the partner, then to shared beneficiaries.
- Flexibility during life: Either partner can change or revoke their mirror will at any time, provided they have mental capacity.
- Common use cases: Couples with shared priorities, such as ensuring children inherit the estate, often choose mirror wills for simplicity.
- Legal recognition: Mirror wills are fully valid under UK law when drafted and signed properly, following the Wills Act 1837.
Mirror wills are often marketed as straightforward and affordable, which makes them appealing to many couples. However, the simplicity that makes them attractive can also conceal potential drawbacks if personal circumstances change or family dynamics shift. That is why examining mirror wills pros and cons in detail is critical before deciding whether they are right for you.
The Advantages of Mirror Wills
Understanding the benefits is the first step in weighing mirror wills pros and cons. For many couples in the UK, mirror wills provide reassurance and clarity, particularly when estate planning feels overwhelming or costly.
1. Cost-Effective Estate Planning
One of the most cited advantages of mirror wills is affordability. Drafting two mirror wills is usually cheaper than preparing two entirely separate wills with different provisions. Solicitors often offer package deals for couples, which can significantly reduce upfront legal fees. For couples who agree on beneficiaries, this makes mirror wills an efficient way to secure their estate plan without unnecessary duplication of work.
2. Simplicity and Clarity
Mirror wills are straightforward to set up and understand. Both partners know their estates will first pass to the surviving partner, and then to the chosen beneficiaries. This clarity is especially valuable for couples who share the same wishes, such as ensuring their children inherit equally. The simplicity also reduces the likelihood of misunderstandings among surviving family members.
3. Certainty for Couples with Shared Goals
For couples who are aligned on their estate planning, mirror wills provide certainty that their joint intentions will be respected. This can bring peace of mind, particularly where the priority is to secure the financial stability of the surviving partner, and then provide for children or dependants after both have passed away.
4. Legally Recognised Protection
Mirror wills are fully valid under UK law, provided they meet the standard requirements for a will (written, signed, witnessed correctly). Having a legally recognised will helps prevent disputes, avoids intestacy rules, and ensures the estate passes according to the couple’s wishes.
5. Faster Drafting and Less Administrative Burden
Because both wills are almost identical, the drafting process is quicker compared to creating two separate wills with different terms. This reduces the administrative burden on both the couple and their solicitor, allowing families to put a plan in place without unnecessary delay.
The Disadvantages of Mirror Wills
While the benefits of mirror wills are appealing, no estate planning tool is without its limitations. To gain a balanced understanding of mirror wills pros and cons, it’s important to examine the risks and potential drawbacks before making a decision.
1. Lack of Binding Effect
Although mirror wills look like a joint plan, they are not legally binding on either partner. Each will is an individual legal document, which means the surviving partner is free to change their will at any time after the first partner’s death. This can create uncertainty if the deceased partner’s wishes relied on both wills remaining unchanged.
Example: A couple may agree that after both pass away, their estate should go to their children. However, after one partner dies, the survivor may remarry or decide to favour new beneficiaries, altering the original shared plan.
2. Risk of Excluding Intended Beneficiaries
Because the surviving partner can change their will, there is a real risk that children or other intended beneficiaries may not ultimately inherit as agreed. This is particularly concerning in blended families, where children from previous relationships might be unintentionally (or deliberately) excluded.
3. Potential for Family Disputes
Disagreements often arise when a surviving partner changes their will, especially if the changes exclude certain family members or favour new relationships. Such disputes can be emotionally and financially draining, often leading to contested probate cases.
4. Limited Flexibility for Complex Estates
Mirror wills work best for couples with relatively straightforward estates and shared goals. They are less suited to more complex financial arrangements involving business interests, overseas property, or multiple layers of beneficiaries. In such cases, bespoke wills or trusts are often more effective.
5. Vulnerability to Changing Circumstances
Life circumstances can change dramatically after one partner’s death. The survivor may remarry, have more children, or face financial challenges that prompt them to change their will. Because mirror wills offer no safeguard against such changes, they can be less reliable for ensuring a long-term legacy.
6. False Sense of Security
Couples may assume that creating mirror wills “locks in” their wishes permanently. In reality, the surviving partner retains full legal freedom to rewrite their will, which may undermine the certainty that mirror wills were intended to provide.
Mirror Wills vs. Other Estate Planning Options
When considering mirror wills pros and cons, it’s crucial to recognise that they are not the only estate planning option available in the UK. Depending on your circumstances, other legal tools may offer more flexibility, protection, or certainty for your intended beneficiaries.
Mirror Wills vs. Joint Wills
A common source of confusion is the difference between mirror wills and joint wills.
- Mirror wills are two separate wills, each reflecting the other’s terms. They are not binding on the surviving partner, who may change their will later.
- Joint wills are a single document binding both partners. Once one partner dies, the terms cannot be changed by the survivor.
While joint wills might seem to offer stronger protection against changes, they are rarely recommended today. Their inflexibility often causes problems, particularly when circumstances evolve after one partner’s death. Mirror wills, while not binding, provide greater autonomy.
Mirror Wills vs. Bespoke Wills
Bespoke wills are tailored to individual circumstances. Unlike mirror wills, which are usually identical, bespoke wills allow each partner to make provisions that reflect their unique wishes.
- Best for couples with different priorities or complex estates.
- Can include detailed instructions on business assets, property abroad, or unequal distribution among children.
- Often more expensive but more precise and reliable in complex family arrangements.
Mirror Wills vs. Discretionary Trusts
A discretionary trust is another alternative, often used where flexibility is essential.
- Allows trustees to decide how assets are distributed, based on changing circumstances.
- Offers tax advantages in some situations.
- Provides protection against risks such as care home fees or creditors.
- More complex and requires ongoing management.
Mirror Wills vs. Life Interest Trusts
A life interest trust allows the surviving partner to benefit from the estate during their lifetime (for example, living in the family home), but ensures that, after their death, the estate passes to the chosen beneficiaries.
- Prevents the surviving partner from redirecting assets away from intended beneficiaries.
- Protects children from being disinherited if the survivor remarries.
- More secure than mirror wills where preserving inheritance for children is a priority.
When Are Mirror Wills the Right Choice?
Mirror wills are not a one-size-fits-all solution, but they remain a popular option because they work well in certain circumstances. To decide whether they align with your needs, it’s helpful to identify the scenarios in which mirror wills are most effective.
1. Couples with Shared, Straightforward Goals
Mirror wills are ideal for couples who are in full agreement about how their estate should be distributed. If both partners want to leave everything to each other and, eventually, to their children or close relatives, mirror wills provide a simple, cost-effective solution.
2. Modest or Simple Estates
For estates without complex financial arrangements—such as business holdings, foreign property, or large investment portfolios—mirror wills are usually sufficient. They avoid unnecessary complexity and ensure assets pass in line with the couple’s wishes.
3. First Marriages or Civil Partnerships
Mirror wills are often suitable for couples in first marriages or civil partnerships with shared children. In these cases, there is usually less risk of competing family claims or complicated inheritance dynamics, making mirror wills a practical choice.
4. Couples Concerned About Costs
Estate planning can be expensive, especially when bespoke legal documents are required. Mirror wills offer an affordable middle ground, providing legal security without the higher costs associated with trusts or customised wills.
5. Couples Who Want a Quick, Legally Valid Solution
If the goal is to put a legally recognised will in place quickly—perhaps due to an upcoming trip, illness, or other urgent circumstances—mirror wills can be prepared and signed promptly.
When Mirror Wills Might Not Be Suitable
While mirror wills provide clarity and affordability for many couples, they are not suitable in every situation. Certain family and financial circumstances expose the limitations of mirror wills and highlight the need for more tailored estate planning.
1. Blended Families
Mirror wills often create challenges where one or both partners have children from previous relationships. Without additional protections, the surviving partner could alter their will to favour their own children, leaving stepchildren excluded. In such cases, life interest trusts or bespoke wills provide stronger safeguards.
2. Complex Estates
If your estate includes business interests, international property, or multiple layers of beneficiaries, mirror wills are unlikely to provide sufficient flexibility. A bespoke will or trust arrangement is usually a better option to avoid unintended tax consequences and disputes.
3. Concern About Control After Death
Some individuals want to ensure their wishes are carried out without risk of alteration by the surviving partner. Because mirror wills are not binding, they may be unsuitable where maintaining strict control over inheritance is essential. A trust-based arrangement is often preferable in such cases.
4. Risk of Remarriage
If the surviving partner remarries, their new marriage automatically revokes their existing will (unless it was made in contemplation of that marriage). This means a mirror will can become invalid, leaving the estate exposed to intestacy rules unless the new partner creates another will.
5. Families with Ongoing Disputes
Where tensions already exist between children, stepchildren, or extended family, mirror wills can add fuel to conflict. The risk of the surviving partner changing their will may be perceived as unfair, making disputes after death more likely.
6. High-Value Estates with Tax Considerations
For estates approaching or exceeding the inheritance tax (IHT) threshold, mirror wills may fail to optimise available tax planning strategies. More sophisticated arrangements—such as discretionary trusts—are often necessary to minimise IHT exposure.
How to Make Mirror Wills in the UK
Once you’ve weighed mirror wills pros and cons and decided they may suit your needs, the next step is to understand the process of creating them. In the UK, wills must follow specific legal requirements to be valid. Failing to meet these can render your will ineffective, leaving your estate subject to intestacy rules.
1. Seek Professional Advice
Although DIY will kits are available, they can create significant risks if completed incorrectly. Most couples benefit from consulting a solicitor who specialises in wills and probate. Professional advice ensures your mirror wills comply with the Wills Act 1837, reflect your wishes accurately, and avoid common pitfalls.
2. Identify Executors
You will each need to appoint executors—the individuals responsible for administering your estate. Many couples name each other as executors, with substitute executors (such as adult children, trusted relatives, or professionals) appointed in case both partners die at the same time.
3. Decide on Beneficiaries
Mirror wills typically follow a two-stage pattern:
- Everything passes to the surviving partner.
- Once both partners have passed, the estate goes to the agreed beneficiaries (often children).
This decision should be made carefully, particularly in blended families or where fairness among beneficiaries is important.
4. Consider Guardianship for Children
For couples with minor children, mirror wills can include the appointment of guardians. This ensures there is a clear legal framework for the care of children should both parents pass away.
5. Drafting the Wills
Your solicitor will draft two separate but identical wills. Each must clearly set out the distribution of your estate, name executors, and cover other provisions such as guardianship.
6. Signing and Witnessing
For a will to be valid in England and Wales, it must be:
- In writing.
- Signed by the testator (the person making the will).
- Witnessed by two independent adults who are not beneficiaries or married to beneficiaries.
Scotland follows a slightly different process, but the principle of independent witnessing still applies.
7. Storing the Wills Safely
Once signed, mirror wills should be stored securely. Options include leaving them with your solicitor, registering them with the National Will Register, or storing them in a safe location at home. Executors should know where to find the wills when needed.
8. Reviewing and Updating
Life circumstances change—marriage, divorce, births, deaths, or changes in financial circumstances can all affect your will. It is advisable to review your mirror wills every 3–5 years or when major life events occur.
Costs of Mirror Wills in the UK
One of the main reasons couples choose mirror wills is affordability. Compared to more complex estate planning arrangements, mirror wills are often the most cost-effective way to ensure basic legal protection. However, prices vary depending on how they are prepared, the complexity of the estate, and the provider you choose.
Average Solicitor Fees
In the UK, solicitors typically charge between £250 and £500 for preparing a pair of mirror wills. Prices at the lower end generally apply to straightforward estates, while the higher end reflects more detailed drafting, advice on inheritance tax planning, or provisions for blended families.
While this may be more expensive than using an online service, professional advice can prevent costly mistakes. A poorly drafted will may lead to disputes or even be declared invalid, which can ultimately cost far more than the initial solicitor’s fee.
Online and Will-Writing Services
Online will-writing platforms and specialist will-writing companies often charge less, with mirror wills starting from around £150–£250. These services may be suitable for couples with very simple estates and no complicating factors. However, unlike solicitors, will-writers are not always legally qualified or regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA). This can present risks if problems arise.
Additional Costs to Consider
- Will storage: Some providers offer secure storage for an annual or one-off fee, typically £20–£50.
- Updates and amendments: Life changes may require updating your mirror wills. Solicitors often charge a fixed fee for amendments or recommend drafting entirely new wills.
- Trust provisions: If you add trust structures within your wills, such as life interest trusts, expect costs to rise significantly, often starting from £600+.
Value vs. Cost
When comparing mirror wills pros and cons, it’s important not to focus solely on the upfront price. The real value lies in ensuring that your estate is distributed as you intend, with minimal risk of disputes or legal complications. Spending a little more on properly drafted wills can save beneficiaries stress, conflict, and money in the long term.
Common Misconceptions About Mirror Wills
Many couples approach mirror wills with assumptions that don’t always align with legal reality. Misunderstanding how they work can lead to poor planning, false expectations, and, ultimately, disputes among beneficiaries. To fully grasp mirror wills pros and cons, it’s important to clear up these common myths.
Misconception 1: Mirror Wills Cannot Be Changed
Some people believe that once mirror wills are signed, they are “locked in” forever. This is not the case. Each will is a separate legal document, and either partner can revoke or change their will at any time, as long as they have mental capacity. After one partner dies, the surviving partner retains full control over their own will.
Misconception 2: Mirror Wills Guarantee Inheritance for Children
While the intention of many mirror wills is to pass the estate to children after both parents die, this is not guaranteed. The surviving partner can change their will, remarry, or choose to redirect assets elsewhere. Children may therefore be left without the inheritance originally planned.
Misconception 3: Mirror Wills Are the Same as Joint Wills
Mirror wills and joint wills are often confused. A joint will is one document binding both partners. Once one dies, the terms cannot be changed by the survivor. Mirror wills, however, are two separate documents—similar in content but independent in law.
Misconception 4: Mirror Wills Work in All Family Situations
Mirror wills are not always suitable for blended families or estates involving stepchildren, businesses, or multiple properties. Assuming they work universally can create serious problems. More tailored estate planning tools may be required in these scenarios.
Misconception 5: Mirror Wills Eliminate Disputes
While mirror wills provide clarity in simple estates, they do not guarantee harmony among family members. If the surviving partner changes their will or favours certain beneficiaries, disputes can still arise.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are mirror wills and why do couples choose them?
Mirror wills are two separate but almost identical wills made by couples. They usually state that everything is left to the surviving partner, and after both partners pass away, the estate is passed to agreed beneficiaries, often children. Couples choose them because they are affordable, simple, and provide peace of mind. However, understanding mirror wills pros and cons is essential before deciding if they are the right solution.
What are the main advantages of mirror wills?
The key benefits include:
- Cost-effectiveness compared to bespoke wills.
- Simplicity in drafting and execution.
- Legal recognition under UK law.
- Certainty for couples who share straightforward estate goals.
These advantages highlight the “pro” side when considering mirror wills pros and cons.
What are the main disadvantages of mirror wills?
The major drawbacks are:
- They are not binding; the survivor can change their will.
- Risk of excluding children or other beneficiaries.
- Vulnerability if the surviving partner remarries.
- Limited use for complex estates with tax or business considerations.
These disadvantages form the “cons” side of mirror wills pros and cons and are crucial for couples to weigh carefully.
Can mirror wills be changed after one partner dies?
Yes. Unlike joint wills, mirror wills are independent documents. Once one partner dies, the surviving partner has full legal freedom to change their will. This flexibility can be positive but is also one of the biggest concerns raised when discussing mirror wills pros and cons.
Are mirror wills legally binding in the UK?
Mirror wills are valid and legally recognised under UK law if signed and witnessed properly. However, they are not binding agreements between partners. The lack of binding effect is a central issue in the debate around mirror wills pros and cons.
Do mirror wills protect children’s inheritance?
Not necessarily. If the surviving partner changes their will, remarries, or favours different beneficiaries, children may not inherit as originally planned. This is one of the key disadvantages often raised in discussions about mirror wills pros and cons. For stronger protection, families may need trusts or bespoke wills.
How much do wills cost in the UK?
On average, solicitor-drafted mirror wills cost between £250–£500. Online services may start from £150. While cheaper options exist, poorly drafted wills can lead to costly disputes. Cost savings are a recognised advantage in mirror wills pros and cons, but value should be judged on both affordability and reliability.,
How much to make a will in the UK?
The cost depends on complexity and whether you use a solicitor, will-writing service, or online platform. For a simple individual will, fees range from £100–£250, while mirror wills for couples often cost between £150–£400. More complex wills involving trusts, tax planning, or overseas assets may exceed £500–£1,000. When thinking about how much to make a will, remember that quality and accuracy matter—spending slightly more on professional drafting can prevent disputes and protect your estate in the long term.
Are mirror wills the same as joint wills?
No. Joint wills are a single binding document, rarely used today because of their inflexibility. Mirror wills are two separate documents that reflect the same intentions but can be changed individually. This difference is an important consideration when evaluating mirror wills pros and cons.
Who should avoid mirror wills?
Mirror wills may not be suitable for:
- Couples with blended families.
- Estates involving businesses, overseas property, or tax planning needs.
- Individuals who want to lock in their wishes without risk of change.
In these cases, the disadvantages outweigh the advantages in the debate on mirror wills pros and cons.
Who are mirror wills best suited for?
They work best for couples with straightforward estates, shared goals, and modest assets. For these families, the advantages often outweigh the drawbacks in mirror wills pros and cons.
Do mirror wills help with inheritance tax planning?
Mirror wills on their own do not usually provide inheritance tax advantages beyond the transferable nil-rate band between spouses. For larger or more complex estates, other structures like trusts may be necessary. This is another area where weighing mirror wills pros and cons is important.
Can disputes arise from mirror wills?
Yes. If the surviving partner changes their will, disputes may arise between stepchildren, new spouses, or other family members. This makes family dynamics a crucial part of evaluating mirror wills pros and cons.
Are Mirror Wills Right for You?
Mirror wills remain one of the most common estate planning tools for couples in the UK. They provide simplicity, affordability, and peace of mind where partners share the same goals. At the same time, they carry risks—particularly around flexibility, blended families, and changes after one partner’s death.
The decision ultimately depends on your personal and financial circumstances. For some couples, the advantages outweigh the drawbacks. For others, especially those with complex estates or family structures, alternatives such as bespoke wills or trusts may be more suitable.
Make the right choice for your legacy—explore if a Mirror Will is truly right for you
Visa · Settlement · Legal Support
